Should I break up with my boyfriend because of his temper?

Rebecca’s story:

I am 23 years old and have been dating him for 2 years. I met him through a friend at work. He is a lawyer. It was practically a blind date. But a blind date turned wonderful. He was quiet and gentle when I was first met him. We hit it off.

We began dating for a few months. He introduced me to his friends and family members. They seemed very nice. He often invited me to most of the parties at his firm. I got to talk with some of the lawyers’ wives. It was quite interesting.

Although we went out for a few months, I didn’t really know him that well. So I tried to find more information about him. I thought what would be the best way to know my boyfriend other than through his friends.

Something got me curious is that his friends often hinted that he has a short temper. I never saw he raise his voice once. My father was a violent man. I have lived some miserable years with him. I never want to live like that ever again. So I wanted to find out if he really has a temper.

I didn’t tell him anything because honestly I didn’t know what to ask. Then one day I witnessed it. One day when we were coming out of a restaurant, there was an incident. An old woman was slowly walking when a man pumped into her. She fell. All of her groceries spilled on the ground. The man wasn’t even bothered to help her. He was too busy fixing up his shirt. He started to walk away.

I ran to that old lady and helped her up. When I was busy gathering her stuffs, my boyfriend was chasing after that man. He jumped on him; beat the heck out of that heartless man. I was stunt. I looked at my boyfriend; flashbacks about my father rushed back.

When I finished helping the lady, I went home immediately. I didn’t meet him afterward. I called him to check on him, but it felt like an obligation.

He tried to call me for days but I tried to avoid him. I told him that I was busy for a few days so I couldn’t talk to him. I was trying to make a decision whether or not I should continue this relationship.

Part of me really wants to be with him. But the other part of me fears to be with him. What if we got married and he got mad at me, is he going to act like this? What if he got violent with me and the children?

Sherry Love’s corner:

You have bad memories about your father and it’s really hard to overcome. Now whenever you saw a man get violent, you thought of what your father did to you.

Now you saw your boyfriend beating up a man and it disturbed you. It’s understandable of what he did. He probably felt like he had to do something. However, that didn’t make what he did right. He could help the lady but he shouldn’t assault that man. He definitely overreacted.

But have you ever asked him why he did it? May be someone he loved was pushed like that lady? Is it possible that he also had bad experiences just like you did and felt that he must do the right thing (according to him)? Is it an isolated incident or it happened all the time? May be he just tried to impress you, proving that he is the man and can protect you?

You have heard from his friends that he has a temper. But have you ever heard them talk about a specific occasion where he went overboard like this incident? I think most people have temper once in a while. You shouldn’t end the relationship just because of this incident. You have to find out what really is going on with him? Talk to him? Find out why he did what he did? Talk more to his friends and family?

You have dated him for two years and it was the only time he lost control of his actions. It’s up to you whether you wanted to spend some more time to see if he is really a violent man like your fear. If you believe that he is, then you probably know what to do. But if there is a chance that he isn’t, then do you really want to throw away a potentially good man?

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

4 comments ↓

#1 Pickletoe on 09.08.08 at 11:50 am

I disagree. I think that if his temper is a big enough problem to be mentioned by his friends, then they are just nicely warning her, or maybe even looking to see how she is taking his (exposed) temper. Maybe it’s even spoiled romances for him in the past.

I think she should talk to him about the incident. She should share her feelings about her reaction to him being violent and ask him if he’s done this in the past.

It might be necessary to end the relationship but at least this way she’ll have all the facts/feelings to consider. Men are on their best behavior while dating, and to see something of this caliber may be revealing a very real tendency for violence.

#2 Janet on 02.25.09 at 6:35 pm

What reaction would you have wanted to happen in this incident? The guy who did nothing to help the old lady did something wrong. Something that your boyfriend saw as rude and horrible. I don’t have a big temper myself, but if I saw something like that, I’m not sure of what my reaction would be. I could have very well attacked the man too. Its like saying you don’t have feelings of punching a man who murdered a baby.

So just ask yourself that. Did he really react in the wrong matter? What could he have done that would have appeased you? Could a good tounge lashing on the man have solved anything?

#3 anu on 05.16.09 at 10:07 am

give the relationship some time.. and then take a call

#4 Naomi on 12.31.09 at 3:24 am

Hi Sherry, I found your site just now through MBC. How interesting to pose questions and answers like this. What a great format!! As far as this story goes, I’m not big on violence (despite my breast pump murdering tendencies). But I think the guy thought he was doing right in defense of the old lady. Who knows. Relationships are so complicated. As people are.

Thank you so much for you commnets on my breast pump assasin story. I’m so glad you enjoyed it. Have a super new year!!!

Leave a Comment